U.S. officials: We will know if Iran cheats on deal
An image of Iranian leaders is projected on a giant screen in front of demonstrators during a rally opposing the nuclear deal with Iranin Times Square in the Manhattan borough of New York.
HomeWorld

U.S. officials: We will know if Iran cheats on deal

SHARE:

Hezbollah snubs U.S. as ‘Satan’ after Iran deal
Britain lifts Iran travel warning
Over 100,000 petition against Saudi king’s French Riviera holiday
Fatah colonel killed in Lebanon's largest refugee camp
President Obama starts two-day Kenya visit
U.S. intelligence officials say they are confident they can verify Iran’s compliance with the recently completed nuclear deal, despite a track record of misjudgments about weapons of mass destruction.

The main reason, according to a classified joint intelligence assessment presented to Congress, is that the deal requires Iran to provide an unprecedented volume of information about nearly every aspect of its existing nuclear program, which Iran insists is peaceful. That data will make checking on compliance easier, officials say, because it will shrink Iran’s capacity to hide a covert weapons program.

“We will have far better insight (into) the industrial aspects of the Iranian nuclear program with this deal than what we have today,” James Clapper, the director of national intelligence, told an audience last month at the Aspen Security Forum.

Outside experts don’t dispute that. But they question - considering past analytical blind spots in the Middle East - whether American spying will really be able to catch every instance of Iranian cheating.

“The intelligence community can rarely guarantee, ‘We’re going find the secret site,’” said David Albright, a former weapons inspector who heads the Institute for Science and International Security. “They have found them before in Iran and that’s good, but I think they are going to have to do more work and bolster their capabilities to find secret sites in Iran in an environment when Iran is taking counter measures against them.”

Skeptics of the deal note that Iran is one of the world’s hardest places in which to spy. Iran’s intelligence agencies have penetrated CIA front companies, executed Western agents and captured a sophisticated U.S. drone.

The CIA has never had much success developing and keeping good intelligence sources in Iran, says Reuel Marc Gerecht, who worked as a CIA operations officer.

“The truth is that the CIA and the NSA are largely flying blind inside the Islamic Republic on the nuclear question,” he wrote recently in the Weekly Standard.

Intelligence officials dispute that, saying their insights into Iran have improved considerably in recent years.

The CIA has “a reasonably high degree of confidence that we would be able to detect Iran if it were trying to deviate from the requirements that they’ve signed up to,” David Cohen, the agency's deputy director, said at the Aspen Security Forum.

The United States, Russia, China, Britain, France and Germany reached the agreement with Iran on July 14 that would curtail its nuclear program in exchange for billions of dollars in relief from economic sanctions. The U.S. Congress is expected to vote next month on a resolution rejecting the agreement.

As part of the deal, Iran agreed to disclose nearly every element of its nuclear supply chain, including people, places, companies and infrastructure – “their entire nose-to-tail process for uranium production and processing,” as one U.S. intelligence official put it, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly.

Those disclosures would vastly increase the chances that intelligence agencies would catch cheating, officials told Congress in classified briefings. That’s because any illicit activity would have to take place outside the established network that had been laid bare to the West. Once the CIA knows all the places Iran has been importing and processing nuclear material, the country would have to develop new avenues to evade detection- a major undertaking. The briefings and the assessment were described by officials only on condition of anonymity.

The intelligence assessment presumes Iran will try to cheat, say officials familiar with it.

Even after 15 years, when restrictions on Iranian nuclear activities are lifted, Iran will still be prohibited from developing a nuclear weapon, and the U.S. will have more ability than it does now to detect any attempt, officials insist.

History provides reasons to be skeptical of U.S. ability to detect and gauge secret Iranian nuclear activity.

Foremost among them are the massive misjudgments in intelligence that helped justify the Iraq war. Nearly every U.S. spy agency concluded with some level of certainty that Saddam Hussein possessed active chemical and biological weapons programs. They were flat wrong.

Officials point out that the Iraq war debacle led to changes. On Iran, for example, agencies brought in “red teams,” both from inside and outside to probe for weaknesses, question assumptions and ponder unlikely scenarios. The Iran analysis has withstood such probing, officials say.

Still, the American intelligence community has misjudged a number of major developments since then, including the Arab Spring, the Russian move into Ukraine and the swift military advance of the Islamic State.

The record on nuclear weapons development is particularly spotty. The CIA missed India’s plan to test nuclear weapons in 1998, for example.
Designed for clickPakistan
Name

Afghanistan,10,Asia,45,Attock,1,Awaran,1,Azad Kashmir,22,Bahawalnagar,1,Bahawalpur,1,Balochistan,64,Barkhan,1,Bhakkar,1,Business,195,Chagai,1,Chakwal,1,China,15,Chiniot,1,Dera Bugti,2,Dera Ghazi Khan,1,Districts of Azad Kashmir,6,Districts of Balochistan,8,Districts of Gilgit Baltistan,7,Districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,6,Districts of Punjab,12,Districts of Sindh,6,Editor's Choice,7,Education,10,Entertainment,142,Faisalabad,1,Fata,4,Gilgit Baltistan,5,Gujranwala,1,Gujrat,2,Gwadar,4,Hafizabad,1,Harnai,1,Headlines,8,Health,74,India,47,Iran,2,Islamabad,75,Jafarabad,1,Jammu and Kashmir,31,Jhal Magsi,1,Jhang,1,Jhelum,3,Kachhi,1,Kalat,1,Karachi,38,Kasur,1,Kech,1,Khanewal,1,Kharan,1,Khushab,1,Khuzdar,2,Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,28,Killa Abdullah,1,Killa Saifullah,1,Kohlu,1,Lahore,12,Lasbela,1,Layyah,1,Lehri,1,Lifestyle,128,Lodhran,1,Loralai,1,Mandi Bahauddin,1,Mardan,1,Mastung,1,Mianwali,1,MiddleEast,1,MQM,4,Multan,2,Musakhel,1,Muslims,6,Muzaffarabad,1,Muzaffargarh,1,Nankana Sahib,1,Narowal,1,Nasirabad,2,National,5,Nushki,1,Okara,1,Operation Zarb-e-Azb,3,Opinion,25,Pakistan,807,Pakpattan,1,Panjgur,1,Peshawar,7,Pics,80,Pishin,1,PMLN,12,Politics,1,PPP,51,PTI,14,Punjab,16,Quetta,14,Rahim Yar Khan,2,Rajanpur,2,Rawalpindi,8,Russia,4,Sahiwal,1,Sargodha,1,Saudi Arabia,1,Sawabi,1,Science,73,Sheikhupura,1,Sherani,1,Shikarpur,1,Sialkot,1,Sibi,1,Sindh,29,Sohbatpur,2,Sports,588,Technology,73,Toba Tek Singh,1,Top News,190,US,31,Vehari,2,Videos,66,Washuk,1,Women,7,World,1197,Zhob,1,Ziarat,1,
ltr
item
Click Pakistan: U.S. officials: We will know if Iran cheats on deal
U.S. officials: We will know if Iran cheats on deal
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhphVAhGIa66wu-KHlJRMvjm8x63BplMVmKy8kumlArGfaQ_wetet0njEUZWGBsx0a_NcVMflAzaNWJb7Gl0MOMhJWod4TyxOzp5VLRVdH8YIHwEcNWzAepzO_JwXc8Fh6S4L3lnyFANclz/s640/protest+against+iran+deal.jpg
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhphVAhGIa66wu-KHlJRMvjm8x63BplMVmKy8kumlArGfaQ_wetet0njEUZWGBsx0a_NcVMflAzaNWJb7Gl0MOMhJWod4TyxOzp5VLRVdH8YIHwEcNWzAepzO_JwXc8Fh6S4L3lnyFANclz/s72-c/protest+against+iran+deal.jpg
Click Pakistan
https://clickpakistan.blogspot.com/2015/08/us-officials-we-will-know-if-iran.html
https://clickpakistan.blogspot.com/
http://clickpakistan.blogspot.com/
http://clickpakistan.blogspot.com/2015/08/us-officials-we-will-know-if-iran.html
true
5553387469600639464
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content